Celebrate the holidays! Save 20% on annual and biennial Premium »
  • French»
  • French Q&A»
  • In the example Il est celui qui mange le plus bruyamment, why is il est used instead of c’est?

In the example Il est celui qui mange le plus bruyamment, why is il est used instead of c’est?

Heather W.C1Kwiziq community member

In the example Il est celui qui mange le plus bruyamment, why is il est used instead of c’est?

I thought when être was followed by a noun or pronoun the subject would be c’est, like c’est mon fils or c’est la mienne. Isn’t celui also a pronoun? Is it because il is also the subject of the verb manger?

This question relates to:French lesson "Le plus/Le moins = The most/the least (Superlative with Adverbs in French)"
Asked 5 years ago
Like0Answer1
Share
AurélieNative French expert teacher in KwiziqCorrect answer

Bonjour Heather !

Indeed, the general rule is to use "c'est", and not "il est" here.This example has now been updated accordingly :)

Merci et bonne journée ! 

Like05 years ago
Share
Heather W. asked:

In the example Il est celui qui mange le plus bruyamment, why is il est used instead of c’est?

I thought when être was followed by a noun or pronoun the subject would be c’est, like c’est mon fils or c’est la mienne. Isn’t celui also a pronoun? Is it because il is also the subject of the verb manger?

Sign in to submit your answer

Don't have an account yet? Join today

« Isn't the meaning of "d'ici neuf heures" actually "within nine hours"?Can I save this dictée? »
Ask a question

Find your French level for FREE

Test your French to the CEFR standard

Find your French level
Clever stuff happening!